Selective Insurance
Work in HR? Unlock Free Profile

Selective Insurance Reviews

35 Reviews
35 Reviews
Rating Trends

Recommend to a friend
Approve of CEO
Selective Insurance Chairman, President, and CEO Gregory E. Murphy
Gregory E. Murphy
20 Ratings

    Clearly disgruntled employees are leaving all the reviews

    • Comp & Benefits
    • Work/Life Balance
    • Senior Management
    • Culture & Values
    • Career Opportunities
    Current Employee - Anonymous Employee
    Current Employee - Anonymous Employee

    I have been working at Selective Insurance for more than 8 years


    I've been here nearly 10 years. I've held a number of positions during that time. I'm making pretty good money. I've always been able to find people willing to invest in me, especially in the regional offices. Co-workers have been great (with some exceptions which you will have anywhere). Great work flexibility which I really appreciate now that I have a family. As long as the work gets done, they don't seem to care if you work 6:30-2:30 or 10-6. That's not an exaggeration as I know people who work those hours at our corporate office. Regional offices won't be as flexible .


    Production roles are demanding, but you can get up to a 40% bonus if celestial bodies align. I do agree that it seems harder to hit your goal every year. Management likes the BHAGs.

    Advice to ManagementAdvice

    Seems like every year or two there's a significant change driven by senior management (regional staffing, underwriting strategy, etc). There's no socialization before it comes down. Eventually reality comes in and the change is moderated or reversed. With regard to the underwriting side of the house, I think Sr Management would benefit from getting more feedback before instituting the change.

    Neutral Outlook
    Approves of CEO

Selective Insurance Interviews

Updated May 28, 2014
Updated May 28, 2014

Interview Experience

Interview Experience


Getting an Interview

Getting an Interview


Interview Difficulty


Interview Difficulty




    Commercial Underwriter Interview

    Anonymous Interview Candidate
    Anonymous Interview Candidate
    Application Details

    I applied through an employee referral - interviewed at Selective Insurance.

    Interview Details

    Phone interview and two in house interviews with HR and hiring manager. They asked the basic interview questions and asked many insurance related and situational questions. The entire process lasted about two weeks before I heard back from HR.

    Interview Questions
    Negotiation Details
    phone call negotiation. I had 24 hours to make decision.
    Accepted Offer
    Positive Experience
    Average Interview

Selective Insurance Awards & Accolades

Let us know if we're missing any workplace or industry recognition – Add an award

Additional Info

Edit Profile
Headquarters Branchville, NJ
Size 1000 to 5000 Employees
Founded Unknown
Type Company - Public (SIGI)
Industry Insurance
Revenue $1 to $2 billion (USD) per year

Selective Insurance Group is trying to be more accepting -- without becoming indiscriminate. Since the early 1990s, the property/casualty insurance holding company has been expanding its service area beyond its native New Jersey (which still accounts for more than 25% of sales) to reach the entire eastern US seaboard and much of the Midwest. Commercial policies sold by its seven subsidiaries include workers' compensation and commercial automobile, property, and liability insurance. Personal lines include homeowners and automobile insurance. The company also offers federal... More

Worked for Selective Insurance? Contribute to the Community!