5 Reasons Your Resume Is More Valuable Than Your Online Professional Profile

Do you wish there was a one-stop resume shop online? Maybe you could just type in a URL, enter a few bullets and voila, your resume would appear. Ever so often thereafter, you could pop in and add a bullet or two that touts your newest achievement. Easy peasy.

While LinkedIn and its advocates have been promoting the resume builder as an effortless replacement to the ‘traditional Word resume,’ several problems with this recommendation exist. For example:

  1. Resumes Are Owned by LinkedIn, Ultimately. Yes, once you’ve signed up for a URL, in theory, you own it until you relinquish it. But the reality is, the LinkedIn site is owned by a corporate entity, not you. Everyone should have their own personal resume that is offline, portable, and easily accessible, and not at risk of evaporating or morphing by powers outside of your control.
  2. Resumes Are Confined by Character Count Rules. Each section has a certain number of characters you can use. Once you’ve populated those, your storytelling ceases. For example, the following describes several sections and their character restrictions: Professional Headline–120 characters; the Summary–2,000 characters; and each Position Description–2,000 characters. While the character counts, at a glance, seem fairly adequate, they do limit creativity and flexibility. Not every resume is alike, and fleshing out your Position Description stories may require more than the allotted number of characters. Marketing your unique value to ABC Company may require you to expand more in one section than another. One size does not fit all.
  3. Resumes Offer Limited Design Capabilities. For example, if you want to embed a chart or graph directly into the Summary section to promptly wow the reader, you cannot. Yes, you can create SlideShares and other visual displays, as attachments to your LinkedIn profile, but that tactic is not as seamless, flexible or visually malleable as sliding your image directly into the design. While you can add, subtract and move sections around, you cannot create unique titles or distinctively design how your sections are presented – they are pre-programmed. As well, LinkedIn resumes do not allow bold-facing or color. If you want to emphasize a few words, a headline or a phrase, you can’t press a boldfacing button, apply unique fonts or incorporate dashes of color. A LinkedIn resume pales in comparison to some of the more intrepid, nuanced and graphically designed resumes that are created in Word.
  4. Resumes All Look Alike. Regardless of the finessing you perform to develop a distinguishing look—even if you cleverly paste in specially designed bullets to introduce your achievements, rearrange sections, add SlideShares or Box.net files and so forth, your profile, at a glance, will visually look like the next candidate’s profile and the next, and so forth. It’s part and parcel to using a pre-programmed style.
  5. Sometimes Too Public. You may be more willing to divulge certain information in a privately submitted resume than you would via a publicly published LinkedIn profile. Particularly, if you are currently employed, you may opt to use your LinkedIn profile as a marketing vehicle for your current company to expand their visibility. In other words, if you are currently employed, your message may be slanted more toward selling your value to your clients, to strategic partners and such, while your offline, Word, resume can directly tout your value to a new job at a different company.

Writing and maintaining a focused and persuasive resume is essential to your career and job search movement. While the initial process can seem daunting, don’t let this derail your efforts. LinkedIn’s resume builder may seem like the easy button to job search success; it’s not. Take the time, and make the intellectual effort to first build a robust, meaningful and convincing Word resume, and then use that content to flesh out your online profiles.

Jacqui Barrett-Poindexter is a Glassdoor career and workplace expert, chief career writer and partner with CareerTrend, and is one of only 28 Master Resume Writers (MRW) globally. An intuitive researcher, she helps professionals unearth compelling career story details to help best present their unique experience, skillset and interests in resumes and other career positioning documents as well as through social media profiles. In addition to being interviewed for television and radio stories, Jacqui has written for the Career Management Alliance Connection monthly newsletter and blog, ExecuNet’s Career Smart Advisor, The Kansas City Star, The Business Journal and The Wall Street Journal. In addition, she and her husband, “Sailor Rob,” host a lively careers-focused blog over at http://careertrend.net/blog. Jacqui also is a power Twitter user listed on several "Best People to Follow” lists for job seekers.

  • Paul Dube

    Hi Jacqui,
    1) I think you meant to use “Your Online Professional Profile (on LinkedIn)” at the start of those points.
    2) You haven’t told us why the Resume is” more valuable”, you just pointed out some minor and ‘potential’ problems with the LinkedIn profile.
    3) You have overlooked the value of the Recommendations section, the ability to find references, and the ability to find connections through which you can get a warm introduction – potentially to the hiring manager on LinkedIn.
    4) You have apparently overlooked the paper resume’s limited reach vs. an online profile.
    5) Most importantly, LinkedIn – and *all* tools, including the paper resume, are not mutually exclusive. We need to use every tool available to us that provides more value than it ‘costs’ (regardless of what that ‘cost’ is – time, $, risk, etc.). This ‘valuation’ (of ‘cost’) is different for everyone and every tool.

    Yes, the paper resume is extremely valuable and necessary. However, don’t lose sight of the one and only purpose of the resume… to get an interview. If it doesn’t get into the hiring manager’s hands, it has failed and is worthless.

  • Kristi Enigl

    Interesting points and I agree that Linked In Resume builder has it limitations, but keep in mind that the people searching for candidates on LI are primarily recruiters and HR personnel. As a former recruiter and hiring manager, I used copy and past every resume I submitted to a client onto our letterhead, stripping out any design, graphs, or fancy fonts. Most recruiters do the same.
    Candidates who submitted resumes with charts and graphs were asked to re-submit a plain text resume, if they were viable to begin with. Fancy resumes won’t make it through an ATS filter either. At the end of the day, the “plain jane” resume that market’s a candidate’s accomplishments and talents to a specific job will fit the bill.
    My two cents worth.
    Kristi Enigl, Global Career Coach

  • Amy Knapp

    I agree that LinkedIn isn’t enough. That’s a given.

    At the same time, our online profiles define us much better than our resumes do. Our resumes give a quick summation of all the things we want an employer to know about us. Meanwhile, our profiles reflect our personalities. They show the sort of people we are; sometimes to our benefit and sometimes to our detriment.

    When I’m hiring a new employee, I spend a lot more time checking out what the candidate gets up to online than I do reading her resume. Perhaps that’s because I’m in a creative field. Either way, I’m convinced the paper resume (and the virtual imitations) are on the way out.