Compare American Family Insurance vs GEICO

See how working at American Family Insurance vs. GEICO compares on a variety of workplace factors. By comparing employers on employee ratings, salaries, reviews, pros/cons, job openings and more, you'll feel one step ahead of the rest. All salaries and reviews are posted by employees working at American Family Insurance vs. GEICO. Learn more about each company and apply to jobs near you.

American Family Insurance

Insurance Carriers

American Family Insurance

Insurance Carriers

GEICO

Insurance Carriers

GEICO

Insurance Carriers

Salaries

Customer Service Representative

157 Salaries

$18 / hr total

157 Salaries

Claims Adjuster

155 Salaries

$62,236 / yr total

155 Salaries

Sales Representative

95 Salaries

$17 / hr total

95 Salaries

Customer Service Representative

1165 Salaries

$21 / hr total

1165 Salaries

Auto Damage Adjuster

689 Salaries

$64,684 / yr total

689 Salaries

Insurance Agent

426 Salaries

$49,310 / yr total

426 Salaries

Employee Ratings

American Family Insurance scored higher in 5 areas: Culture & Values, Work-life balance, CEO Approval, Recommend to a friend and Positive Business Outlook.

GEICO scored higher in 3 areas: Diversity & Inclusion, Compensation & Benefits and Career Opportunities.

Both tied in 2 areas: Overall Rating and Senior Management.

Overall rating

3.2

★★★★★

Based on 1725 reviews

3.2

★★★★★

Based on 1725 reviews

3.2★

Culture & Values

Higher rating

3.2★

Higher

Culture & Values

3.6★

Diversity & Inclusion

3.6★

Diversity & Inclusion

3.3★

Work-life balance

Higher rating

3.3★

Higher

Work-life balance

2.7★

Senior Management

2.7★

Senior Management

3.5★

Compensation & Benefits

3.5★

Compensation & Benefits

3.0★

Career Opportunities

3.0★

Career Opportunities

Employee sentiment

48%CEO Approval

Bill Westrate

48%CEO Approval

Bill Westrate

47%

47%Recommend to a friend

American Family Insurance employees rated their Recommend to a friend 2% higher than GEICO employees rated theirs.

47%

47%Recommend to a friend

40%

40%Positive Business Outlook

American Family Insurance employees rated their Positive Business Outlook 1% higher than GEICO employees rated theirs.

40%

40%Positive Business Outlook

Overall rating

3.2

★★★★★

Based on 8810 reviews

3.2

★★★★★

Based on 8810 reviews

3.0★

Culture & Values

3.0★

Culture & Values

3.7★

Diversity & Inclusion

Higher rating

3.7★

Higher

Diversity & Inclusion

2.8★

Work-life balance

2.8★

Work-life balance

2.7★

Senior Management

2.7★

Senior Management

3.6★

Compensation & Benefits

Higher rating

3.6★

Higher

Compensation & Benefits

3.4★

Career Opportunities

Higher rating

3.4★

Higher

Career Opportunities

Employee sentiment

46%CEO Approval

Todd Combs

46%CEO Approval

Todd Combs

45%

45%Recommend to a friend

45%

45%Recommend to a friend

39%

39%Positive Business Outlook

39%

39%Positive Business Outlook

What Employees Say

"Work life balance" was the most mentioned Pro at American Family Insurance. "Pay and benefits" was the most mentioned Pro at GEICO. GEICO had 297 more reviews than American Family Insurance that mentioned "Work life balance" as a Con.

Trending keywords

Pros

"Work life balance"in 81 reviews

"Work from home"in 39 reviews

Cons

"Work life balance"in 40 reviews

"Upper management"in 45 reviews

Trending keywords

Pros

"Pay and benefits"in 371 reviews

"Profit sharing"in 1077 reviews

Cons

"Work life balance"in 337 reviews

"No work life"in 112 reviews

Featured Review

5.0

★★★★★

Mar 21, 2023

"Excellent Company, Culture & Benefits"

Current Employee - Project Manager

Pros

I love working for AmFam. I am a fairly new employee and have been so pleased with my decision to join the team. My team is very competent, my manager is engaged, and the work is rewarding.

Cons

Honestly, none. I truly love working for AmFam.

Featured Review

5.0

★★★★★

Mar 28, 2023

"Good/Bad"

Former Employee - Title Processor

Pros

Profit sharing management work perks events

Cons

Call volume under paid overworked for pay given