Compare American Family Insurance vs Liberty Mutual Insurance

See how working at American Family Insurance vs. Liberty Mutual Insurance compares on a variety of workplace factors. By comparing employers on employee ratings, salaries, reviews, pros/cons, job openings and more, you'll feel one step ahead of the rest. All salaries and reviews are posted by employees working at American Family Insurance vs. Liberty Mutual Insurance. Learn more about each company and apply to jobs near you.
American Family Insurance company icon

American Family Insurance

Insurance Carriers

American Family Insurance

Insurance Carriers
Liberty Mutual Insurance company icon

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Insurance Carriers

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Insurance Carriers

Salaries

Claims Adjuster
154 Salaries
$62,239 / yr total
154 Salaries
Sales Representative
95 Salaries
$17 / hr total
95 Salaries
Customer Service Representative
157 Salaries
$18 / hr total
157 Salaries
Claims Adjuster
532 Salaries
$58,449 / yr total
532 Salaries
Sales Representative
422 Salaries
$42,764 / yr total
422 Salaries
Customer Service Representative
266 Salaries
$44,977 / yr total
266 Salaries

Employee Ratings

Liberty Mutual Insurance scored higher in 10 areas: Overall Rating, Culture & Values, Diversity & Inclusion, Work-life balance, Senior Management, Compensation & Benefits, Career Opportunities, CEO Approval, Recommend to a friend and Positive Business Outlook.
Overall rating
3.2
Based on 1725 reviews
3.2
Based on 1725 reviews
3.2
Culture & Values
3.2
Culture & Values
3.6
Diversity & Inclusion
3.6
Diversity & Inclusion
3.3
Work-life balance
3.3
Work-life balance
2.7
Senior Management
2.7
Senior Management
3.5
Compensation & Benefits
3.5
Compensation & Benefits
3.0
Career Opportunities
3.0
Career Opportunities
Employee sentiment
American Family Insurance Ceo Bill Westrate
48%CEO Approval
Bill Westrate
American Family Insurance Ceo Bill Westrate
48%CEO Approval
Bill Westrate
47%
47%Recommend to a friend
47%
47%Recommend to a friend
40%
40%Positive Business Outlook
40%
40%Positive Business Outlook
Overall rating
3.9
Based on 7749 reviews
3.9
Based on 7749 reviews
4.1
Culture & Values
Higher rating
4.1
Higher
Culture & Values
4.2
Diversity & Inclusion
Higher rating
4.2
Higher
Diversity & Inclusion
3.9
Work-life balance
Higher rating
3.9
Higher
Work-life balance
3.7
Senior Management
Higher rating
3.7
Higher
Senior Management
4.0
Compensation & Benefits
Higher rating
4.0
Higher
Compensation & Benefits
3.8
Career Opportunities
Higher rating
3.8
Higher
Career Opportunities
Employee sentiment
Liberty Mutual Insurance Ceo Tim Sweeney
87%CEO Approval
Tim Sweeney
Liberty Mutual Insurance Ceo Tim Sweeney
87%CEO Approval
Tim Sweeney
76%
76%Recommend to a friend
Liberty Mutual Insurance employees rated their Recommend to a friend 29% higher than American Family Insurance employees rated theirs.
76%
76%Recommend to a friend
71%
71%Positive Business Outlook
Liberty Mutual Insurance employees rated their Positive Business Outlook 31% higher than American Family Insurance employees rated theirs.
71%
71%Positive Business Outlook

What Employees Say

Liberty Mutual Insurance had 654 more reviews than American Family Insurance that mentioned "Work life balance" as a Pro. Liberty Mutual Insurance had 273 more reviews than American Family Insurance that mentioned "Work from home" as a Pro. Liberty Mutual Insurance had 352 more reviews than American Family Insurance that mentioned "Work life balance" as a Con.
Trending keywords
Trending keywords
Pros
"Work life balance"in 81 reviews
"Work from home"in 39 reviews
Cons
"Work life balance"in 40 reviews
"Upper management"in 45 reviews
Trending keywords
Pros
"Work life balance"in 735 reviews
"Work from home"in 312 reviews
Cons
"Work life balance"in 392 reviews
"No work life"in 94 reviews
Featured Review
Featured Review
5.0
Mar 26, 2023

Current Employee - Senior Claims Adjuster

Pros

Great place to work for sure

Cons

Don’t have anything bad to say

Featured Review
5.0
Mar 3, 2023

Current Employee - Senior Recruiter

Pros

Liberty is the best company I have ever worked for. On top of the great culture and the people, they make sure the employees feel heard and valued. Development is also important at Liberty and it's a... great place to build your career. I'm most impressed by how Diversity, Equity & Inclusion is prioritized within the whole company.

Cons

Perfect company does not exist but it's hard to point out a con at Liberty. Depending on your role, it may be challenging to move to a different department. But there are opportunities you can take... on to develop your skills, it just takes time.

Job Openings

Liberty Mutual Insurance has 1,345 more recently posted open jobs than American Family Insurance.
Liberty Mutual Insurance company logo1,414 jobs at Liberty Mutual Insurance
View All Jobs >
Liberty Mutual Insurance company logo1,414 jobs
View All Jobs >

Want to hear more about American Family Insurance and Liberty Mutual Insurance employees?

Ask anonymous questions on Fishbowl and get real time answers from American Family Insurance and Liberty Mutual Insurance employees and others in your industry

Want to hear more about American Family Insurance and Liberty Mutual Insurance employees?

Ask anonymous questions on Fishbowl and get real time answers from American Family Insurance and Liberty Mutual Insurance employees and others in your industry