Compare J. Crew vs Macy's

See how working at J. Crew vs. Macy's compares on a variety of workplace factors. By comparing employers on employee ratings, salaries, reviews, pros/cons, job openings and more, you'll feel one step ahead of the rest. All salaries and reviews are posted by employees working at J. Crew vs. Macy's. Learn more about each company and apply to jobs near you.
J. Crew company icon

J. Crew

Department, Clothing & Shoe Stores

J. Crew

Department, Clothing & Shoe Stores
Macy's company icon

Macy's

Department, Clothing & Shoe Stores

Macy's

Department, Clothing & Shoe Stores

Salaries

Sales Associate
1018 Salaries
$15 / hr total
1018 Salaries
Retail Sales Associate
252 Salaries
$12 / hr total
252 Salaries
Stylist
220 Salaries
$14 / hr total
220 Salaries
Sales Associate
3249 Salaries
$15 / hr total
3249 Salaries
Retail Sales Associate
1103 Salaries
$15 / hr total
1103 Salaries
Cosmetics Counter Manager
357 Salaries
$18 / hr total
357 Salaries

Employee Ratings

J. Crew scored higher in 10 areas: Overall Rating, Culture & Values, Diversity & Inclusion, Work-life balance, Senior Management, Compensation & Benefits, Career Opportunities, CEO Approval, Recommend to a friend and Positive Business Outlook.
Overall rating
3.9
Based on 3671 reviews
3.9
Based on 3671 reviews
3.7
Culture & Values
Higher rating
3.7
Higher
Culture & Values
3.9
Diversity & Inclusion
Higher rating
3.9
Higher
Diversity & Inclusion
3.7
Work-life balance
Higher rating
3.7
Higher
Work-life balance
3.5
Senior Management
Higher rating
3.5
Higher
Senior Management
3.5
Compensation & Benefits
Higher rating
3.5
Higher
Compensation & Benefits
3.4
Career Opportunities
Higher rating
3.4
Higher
Career Opportunities
Employee sentiment
J. Crew Ceo Libby Wadle
79%CEO Approval
Libby Wadle
J. Crew Ceo Libby Wadle
79%CEO Approval
Libby Wadle
69%
69%Recommend to a friend
J. Crew employees rated their Recommend to a friend 12% higher than Macy's employees rated theirs.
69%
69%Recommend to a friend
50%
50%Positive Business Outlook
J. Crew employees rated their Positive Business Outlook 6% higher than Macy's employees rated theirs.
50%
50%Positive Business Outlook
Overall rating
3.4
Based on 26020 reviews
3.4
Based on 26020 reviews
3.4
Culture & Values
3.4
Culture & Values
3.8
Diversity & Inclusion
3.8
Diversity & Inclusion
3.2
Work-life balance
3.2
Work-life balance
3.0
Senior Management
3.0
Senior Management
3.1
Compensation & Benefits
3.1
Compensation & Benefits
3.2
Career Opportunities
3.2
Career Opportunities
Employee sentiment
Macy's Ceo Jeff Gennette
68%CEO Approval
Jeff Gennette
Macy's Ceo Jeff Gennette
68%CEO Approval
Jeff Gennette
56%
56%Recommend to a friend
56%
56%Recommend to a friend
44%
44%Positive Business Outlook
44%
44%Positive Business Outlook

What Employees Say

Macy's had 1,575 more reviews than J. Crew that mentioned "Employee discount" as a Pro. Macy's had 525 more reviews than J. Crew that mentioned "Work life balance" as a Con.
Trending keywords
Trending keywords
Pros
"Great discount"in 317 reviews
"Employee discount"in 313 reviews
Cons
"Part time"in 112 reviews
"Work life balance"in 41 reviews
Trending keywords
Pros
"Work life balance"in 602 reviews
"Employee discount"in 1888 reviews
Cons
"Work life balance"in 566 reviews
"Credit cards"in 1054 reviews
Featured Review
Featured Review
5.0
Oct 19, 2022

Current Employee - Sales Associate

Pros

Great environment to learn sales with a bit of a higher price tag

Cons

not always organized on back end

Featured Review
5.0
Aug 23, 2022

Former Employee - Hospitality Industry Professional

Pros

Flexible Work Schedule and earning 3% commission on top o a base pay ob$16 per hour really brought in nice paychecks. Also being paid weekly was a huge benefit to managing my expenses. Diverse... community of coworkers and agree with their service philosophy of Yes! We can! Really able to focus on customer care and personalized service

Cons

Everytime I have worked for Macys and I have been at three different locations being short staffed was generally an issue but it gave me more opportunities for promotion so not really a con just an... observation

Job Openings

Macy's has 5,047 more recently posted open jobs than J. Crew.

Want to hear more about J. Crew and Macy's employees?

Ask anonymous questions on Fishbowl and get real time answers from J. Crew and Macy's employees and others in your industry

Want to hear more about J. Crew and Macy's employees?

Ask anonymous questions on Fishbowl and get real time answers from J. Crew and Macy's employees and others in your industry