Compare PetSmart vs Menards

See how working at PetSmart vs. Menards compares on a variety of workplace factors. By comparing employers on employee ratings, salaries, reviews, pros/cons, job openings and more, you'll feel one step ahead of the rest. All salaries and reviews are posted by employees working at PetSmart vs. Menards. Learn more about each company and apply to jobs near you.
PetSmart company icon

PetSmart

Pet & Pet Supplies Stores

PetSmart

Pet & Pet Supplies Stores
Menards company icon

Menards

Home Furniture & Housewares Stores

Menards

Home Furniture & Housewares Stores

Salaries

Cashier
672 Salaries
$14 / hr total
672 Salaries
Sales Associate/Cashier
393 Salaries
$15 / hr total
393 Salaries
Manager
126 Salaries
$26 / hr total
126 Salaries
Cashier
636 Salaries
$15 / hr total
636 Salaries
Sales Associate
758 Salaries
$19 / hr total
758 Salaries
Department Manager
264 Salaries
$23 / hr total
264 Salaries

Employee Ratings

PetSmart scored higher in 2 areas: Culture & Values and Diversity & Inclusion.
Menards scored higher in 8 areas: Overall Rating, Work-life balance, Senior Management, Compensation & Benefits, Career Opportunities, CEO Approval, Recommend to a friend and Positive Business Outlook.
Overall rating
3.3
★★★★★
Based on 9092 reviews
3.3
★★★★★
Based on 9092 reviews
3.3★
Culture & Values
Higher rating
3.3★
Higher
Culture & Values
3.8★
Diversity & Inclusion
Higher rating
3.8★
Higher
Diversity & Inclusion
3.0★
Work-life balance
3.0★
Work-life balance
2.9★
Senior Management
2.9★
Senior Management
3.1★
Compensation & Benefits
3.1★
Compensation & Benefits
3.2★
Career Opportunities
3.2★
Career Opportunities
Employee sentiment
PetSmart Ceo J.K. Symancyk
46%CEO Approval
J.K. Symancyk
PetSmart Ceo J.K. Symancyk
46%CEO Approval
J.K. Symancyk
50%
50%Recommend to a friend
50%
50%Recommend to a friend
40%
40%Positive Business Outlook
40%
40%Positive Business Outlook
Overall rating
3.5
★★★★★
Based on 5797 reviews
3.5
★★★★★
Based on 5797 reviews
3.2★
Culture & Values
3.2★
Culture & Values
3.5★
Diversity & Inclusion
3.5★
Diversity & Inclusion
3.1★
Work-life balance
Higher rating
3.1★
Higher
Work-life balance
3.1★
Senior Management
Higher rating
3.1★
Higher
Senior Management
3.3★
Compensation & Benefits
Higher rating
3.3★
Higher
Compensation & Benefits
3.6★
Career Opportunities
Higher rating
3.6★
Higher
Career Opportunities
Employee sentiment
Menards Ceo John R. Menard Jr.
55%CEO Approval
John R. Menard Jr.
Menards Ceo John R. Menard Jr.
55%CEO Approval
John R. Menard Jr.
65%
65%Recommend to a friend
Menards employees rated their Recommend to a friend 15% higher than PetSmart employees rated theirs.
65%
65%Recommend to a friend
56%
56%Positive Business Outlook
Menards employees rated their Positive Business Outlook 16% higher than PetSmart employees rated theirs.
56%
56%Positive Business Outlook

What Employees Say

"Working with animals" was the most mentioned Pro at PetSmart. "Pay on weekends" was the most mentioned Pro at Menards. Menards had 25 more reviews than PetSmart that mentioned "Work life balance" as a Con.
Trending keywords
Trending keywords
Pros
"Working with animals"in 561 reviews
"Working with dogs"in 135 reviews
Cons
"Work life balance"in 78 reviews
"Low pay"in 225 reviews
Read PetSmart reviews
Trending keywords
Pros
"Pay on weekends"in 155 reviews
"Profit sharing"in 465 reviews
Cons
"Work life balance"in 103 reviews
"Long hours"in 239 reviews
Read Menards reviews
Featured Review
Featured Review
5.0
★★★★★
Oct 9, 2023
"Great w/l balance."

Current Employee - Team Lead

Pros

Commitments to local charity organizations are a priority for PetSmart.

Cons

Not enough hours budgeted to complete tasks because your working multiple departments at the same time.

Read more PetSmart reviews (9300)
Read more PetSmart reviews (9300)
Featured Review
5.0
★★★★★
Sep 16, 2023
"Assistant GM"

Current Employee - Assistant General Manager

Pros

Staying Busy, Learning New Challenges, Work with new team members, being involved in all operations of the business

Cons

Not Having a steady schedule with weekends off

Read more Menards reviews (5941)
Read more Menards reviews (5941)

Job Openings

PetSmart has 21,718 more recently posted open jobs than Menards.
PetSmart company logo22,719 jobs at PetSmart
View All Jobs >
PetSmart company logo22,719 jobs
View All Jobs >
IT Analytics InternshipPhoenix, AZ
30d+
IT Analytics InternshipPhoenix, AZ
30d+
Early Morning StockerTinley Park, IL
30d+
Early Morning StockerTinley Park, IL
30d+
Early Morning StockerLauderhill, FL
30d+
Early Morning StockerLauderhill, FL
30d+
HR Analytics InternshipPhoenix, AZ
30d+
HR Analytics InternshipPhoenix, AZ
30d+
Menards company logo1,001 jobs at Menards
View All Jobs >
Menards company logo1,001 jobs
View All Jobs >
Distribution InternshipShelby, IA
30d+
Distribution InternshipShelby, IA
30d+
Outside Yard/ReceivingPeoria, IL
Today
Outside Yard/ReceivingPeoria, IL
Today
StockerMentor, OH
Today
StockerMentor, OH
Today
StockerDavison, MI
30d+
StockerDavison, MI
30d+

Want to hear more about PetSmart and Menards employees?

Ask anonymous questions on Fishbowl and get real time answers from PetSmart and Menards employees and others in your industry

Want to hear more about PetSmart and Menards employees?

Ask anonymous questions on Fishbowl and get real time answers from PetSmart and Menards employees and others in your industry