Compare PetSmart vs Old Navy BETA

See how working at PetSmart vs. Old Navy compares on a variety of workplace factors. By comparing employers on employee ratings, salaries, reviews, pros/cons, job openings and more, you'll feel one step ahead of the rest. All salaries and reviews are posted by employees working at PetSmart vs. Old Navy. Learn more about each company and apply to jobs near you.

PetSmart

Old Navy

Employee Ratings

PetSmart scored higher in 2 areas: Career Opportunities and Compensation & Benefits.
Old Navy scored higher in 7 areas: Overall Rating, Work-life balance, Senior Management, Culture & Values, CEO Approval, % Recommend to a friend and Positive Business Outlook.

Overall Rating

(full-time and part-time employees only)

Overall Rating

(full-time and part-time employees only)

3.4

★★★★★

(based on 7351 reviews)

Overall Rating

(full-time and part-time employees only)

3.5

★★★★★

(based on 9987 reviews)

Career Opportunities

3.3

★★★★★

Career Opportunities

3.2

★★★★★

Compensation & Benefits

3.2

★★★★★

Compensation & Benefits

3.1

★★★★★

Work-life balance

3.1

★★★★★

Work-life balance

3.3

★★★★★

Senior Management

2.9

★★★★★

Senior Management

3.2

★★★★★

Old Navy employees rated their Senior Management 0.3 higher than PetSmart employees rated theirs.

Culture & Values

3.3

★★★★★

Culture & Values

3.6

★★★★★

Old Navy employees rated their Culture & Values 0.3 higher than PetSmart employees rated theirs.

CEO Approval

49%

49%J.K. Symancyk

CEO Approval

69%

69%Sonia Syngal

Old Navy employees rated their CEO Approval 20% higher than PetSmart employees rated theirs.

% Recommend to a friend

54%

% Recommend to a friend

61%

Old Navy employees rated their % Recommend to a friend 7% higher than PetSmart employees rated theirs.

Positive Business Outlook

42%

Positive Business Outlook

46%

Old Navy employees rated their Positive Business Outlook 4% higher than PetSmart employees rated theirs.

Salaries

Old Navy has 2,158 more total submitted salaries than PetSmart.

Salaries for similar jobs

Sales Associate/Cashier230 Salaries

$11/hr

Store Manager493 Salaries

$83,265/yr

Inventory Leader345 Salaries

$46,465/yr

See more PetSmart salaries (13324)

Salaries for similar jobs

Sales Associate2418 Salaries

$11/hr

Retail Sales Associate534 Salaries

$11/hr

Business Operations Manager246 Salaries

$53,928/yr

See more Old Navy salaries (15482)

What Employees Say

"Working with animals" was the most mentioned Pro at PetSmart.
"Employee discount" was the most mentioned Pro at Old Navy.
"Animals" was the most mentioned Con at PetSmart.
"Credit cards" was the most mentioned Con at Old Navy.

Pros

"Working with animals"(in 561 reviews)

"Animal"(in 211 reviews)

Pros

"Employee discount"(in 719 reviews)

"Old navy"(in 577 reviews)

Cons

"Animals"(in 677 reviews)

"Dogs"(in 495 reviews)

Cons

"Credit cards"(in 632 reviews)

"Old navy"(in 624 reviews)

Read PetSmart reviews

Read Old Navy reviews

Featured Review

"Great place to work"Apr 1, 2022

★★★★★

Former Employee - Assistant Manager

I worked at PetSmart full-time

Pros

Great to work with customers pets

Cons

Pay scale could improve a bit

Job Postings

PetSmart has 17,899 more recently posted open jobs than Old Navy.

Recent Jobs

21,064 Jobs

View All Jobs

DC Rack Associate: BethelBethel, PA

30+ days ago

Distribution Center Warehouse AssociateUtica, IL

30+ days ago

DC Warehouse 2nd Shift - Afternoon/EveningOttawa, IL

30+ days ago

Customer Service or Sales RepresentativeMesa, AZ

30+ days ago

Recent Jobs

3,165 Jobs

View All Jobs

Full Time Stock AssociateFall River, MA

Today

Sales Associate, Full Time - 2 Folsom St NEW STORESan Francisco, CA

8 days ago

Fitting Room AttendantMiramar Beach, FL

3 days ago

Assistant ManagerSaint George, UT

30+ days ago