Working at GNY Insurance Companies | Glassdoor

GNY Insurance Companies Overview

New York, NY
201 to 500 employees
Company - Private
$100 to $500 million (USD) per year
Greater New York Mutual Insurance Companies (“GNY”) is a financially strong and growing A+ rated property/casualty mutual insurance Company, headquartered in New York City. We have additional offices in New Jersey, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Maryland.

Mission: Through 17 U.S. presidents, 20 economic recessions, and 7 wars, GNY Insurance has stood for one unwavering principle: providing consistent financial stability for its customers and brokers. We believe it's the one thing you should never have to question about

GNY Insurance Companies – Why Work For Us?


Standing Strong Since 1914.

Greater New York Mutual Insurance Company (GNY) has stood strong through 17 U.S. presidents, 7 major wars and 20 economic recessions. Throughout the years, our guiding principle has remained the same - Provide consistent financial stability and outstanding service for our customers.

Together with our three wholly owned subsidiaries - Insurance Company of Greater New York, Strathmore Insurance Company and GNY Custom Insurance Company - we provide customized insurance solutions for:

  • Apartment buildings, condos and co-ops
  • Bowling centers
  • Commercial bakeries
  • Hotels
  • Light industrial businesses
  • Microbreweries
  • Movie theaters
  • Office buildings
  • Private clubs
  • Restaurants
  • Self-storage
  • Shopping centers

We also offer others types of insurance protection to round-out our property and liability packages.


Why is GNY a great place to work?

  • Dynamic and down to earth people
  • Team-oriented environment
  • Exciting office locations
  • Excellent benefits
  • Competitive salaries
  • Opportunities for advancement including stellar training programs

Our 2016 Employee Engagement Survey found...

  • Nearly 80% of the total population polled responded to the survey request.
  • More than half of our respondents either agreed or strongly agreed on the availability of career advancement opportunities at GNY.
  • 72% of respondents either agreed or strongly agreed that GNY is dedicated to their professional development.
  • 91% of respondents either agreed or strongly agreed that they are motivated to give their best effort every day at work.
  • The majority of the respondents stated salary and discretionary compensation is most important to them, with job security coming in as a close second.
  • 88% of respondents either agreed or strongly agreed that they have a good working relationship with their supervisor and 93% either agreed or strongly agreed that they a good working relationship with their co-workers.
  • 76% of respondents said that they would recommend GNY as an employer to a friend.



We recruit innovative thinkers, team players, and confident risk-takers to carry on our rich tradition of insurance excellence.

This program lasts approximately 2 years and offers a rare opportunity for individuals to receive intensive, hands-on training from expert professionals that can be directly transferred to the field.

We offer a competitive starting salary with frequent increases  (for 2 years assuming you meet or exceed performance expectations).

You will be joining a team of one of the most trusted names in the property and casualty insurance industry.

Why Underwritng?

Do you enjoy analyzing information and paying close attention to detail?

If so, then underwriting can be an excellent career choice. It is important for underwriters to demonstrate good judgment in order to make reliable and sound insurance decisions. Because much of the underwriter’s work involves dealing with agents and other insurance professionals, excellent communication and interpersonal skills are also essential.

Why Claims?

Do you enjoy investigating and verifying facts? Do you love to negotiate?

If so, then a career as a Claims Examiner might be for you. Claims Examiners verify and analyze data used in settling claims to ensure that claims are valid and covered under the policy provisions and settlements are made according to company practices and procedures.


GNY offers a comprehensive benefits plan designed to meet the needs of all our employees:

  • Medical/Dental/Vision discount
  • Pension plan (100% company paid)
  • 401(k) retirement plan with matching contributions
  • Short-term and long-term disability coverage
  • Life insurance
  • Flexible spending accounts
  • Generous Paid Time Off (PTO) that increases with job tenure
  • 100% Tuition/education reimbursement
  • Bonuses for passing insurance related exams such as CPCU
  • Company social events and charity fundraisers 


Culture is a large part of what makes an organization tick. We spend the majority of our time at work and we believe that our work environment at GNY is what makes us a company of choice.

People First

  • We are a firm believer of "doing the right thing" not only for our customers but our employees.
  • Our average job tenure is 9 years!


  • We are financially strong. We have been A+ rated by A.M. Best for 40 years in a row. Few companies have acheived this accolade.

Passion in what we do

  • We encourage and support our employees to pursue their career ambitions by providing incentives for additional education.
  • We are dedicated to learning and development by various training programs and initiatives.

GNY Insurance Companies Reviews

Rating TrendsRating Trends
Recommend to a friend
Approve of CEO
(no image)
Elizabeth Heck
10 Ratings
  • Featured Review

    Helpful (2)

    "Encouraging and supportive team work environment that always strives to do the right thing."

    • Work/Life Balance
    • Culture & Values
    • Career Opportunities
    • Comp & Benefits
    • Senior Management
    Current Employee - Anonymous Employee
    Current Employee - Anonymous Employee
    Positive Outlook
    Approves of CEO

    I have been working at GNY Insurance Companies full-time (More than 8 years)


    If you are smart and want to grow with a company that supports you, if you want to work for a company that wants and listens to your opinions, and doesn't have all of the political layers and bureaucracy that larger companies have where you feel lost in the masses, this is a great company to work for. The people are fantastic and supportive and the philosophy is to make sound decisions, develop and maintain long term relationships, and grow the business for the benefit of all.


    The work environment is more demanding than in year's past. Employees are expected to do more, have opinions they can support, and find solutions. Employees are given more ownership of their work and those that excel are rewarded, but the expectations of all have grown and not everyone can or is willing to meet the challenge.

    Advice to Management

    Keep communicating with employees so that those that fear or are challenged by the idea of change understand how important and necessary it is for survival.

See All 38 Reviews

GNY Insurance Companies Photos

GNY Insurance Companies photo of: New Jersey Office
GNY Insurance Companies photo of: New Business Underwriting
GNY Insurance Companies photo of: Renewal Underwriting
GNY Insurance Companies photo of: Supporting New York commerical businesses since 1914
GNY Insurance Companies photo of: Maryland Branch
GNY Insurance Companies photo of: CEO Warren Heck, COO Liz Heck and team members
See All PhotosSee All

GNY Insurance Companies Interviews



Getting an Interview

Getting an Interview





    Junior Quality Control Analyst Interview

    Anonymous Employee in East Brunswick, NJ
    Accepted Offer
    Positive Experience
    Average Interview


    I applied through an employee referral. I interviewed at GNY Insurance Companies (East Brunswick, NJ) in April 2017.


    I originally applied through a referral and within a couple of days I received a phone call from HR providing me with information of the company and the role itself. I was then setup with an interview for the next following week. I met with 3 individuals during the interview and the interview went well. A lot of it was more conversational.

    Interview Questions

    • How do you prioritize which problem should be resolved first if you have someone in front of you, on the phone, and email?

      What are your experiences?   Answer Question
See All 10 Interviews

GNY Insurance Companies Awards & Accolades

  • A+ Rated, A.M. Best, 2014

Work at GNY Insurance Companies? Share Your Experiences

GNY Insurance Companies
  • Star
  • Star
  • Star
  • Star
  • Star
Click to Rate