Working at HM Insurance Group | Glassdoor

HM Insurance Group Overview

Work Here? Get a Free Employer Account
Pittsburgh, PA
201 to 500 employees
Subsidiary or Business Segment
Insurance Carriers
$25 to $50 million (USD) per year
American Independence, Independence Holding, Maiden
Highmark Health affiliate HM Insurance Group is a national insurance company that works to protect businesses from the potential financial risks associated with health costs. Headquartered in Pittsburgh with offices in 23 locations across the nation, HM Insurance Group is ... Read more

HM Insurance Group Reviews

Rating TrendsRating Trends
Recommend to a friend
Approve of CEO
(no image)
F.G. "Chip" Merkel
3 Ratings
  • Helpful (1)

    "Supportive management."

    • Work/Life Balance
    • Culture & Values
    • Career Opportunities
    • Comp & Benefits
    • Senior Management
    Current Employee - Registered Nurse in Pitts, PA
    Current Employee - Registered Nurse in Pitts, PA
    Positive Outlook
    No opinion of CEO

    I have been working at HM Insurance Group full-time (More than 5 years)


    Benefits and employee perks increase value of employee package along with work from home options. Tuition reimbursement allows for career growth. Management is approachable and supportive.


    Long hours are frequent due to volume of work. Have lower salary rages compared to competitors in the industry. Annual review process does not adequately allow for over achievers to be recognized.

    Advice to Management

    Need to increase salary ranges, Need to change titles to be similar to lie roles with competitors.

See All 10 Reviews

HM Insurance Group Interviews



Getting an Interview

Getting an Interview




  1. Helpful (1)  

    Supervisor, United Way Helpline Interview

    Anonymous Interview Candidate in Pittsburgh, PA
    No Offer
    Negative Experience
    Average Interview


    I applied online. The process took 2 weeks. I interviewed at HM Insurance Group (Pittsburgh, PA).


    There were a total of 4 interviews completed - an initial phone interview/screening, then meeting with each individual i would be working with separately.

    The phone interview was fine. The call was supposed to come at a specific time and was approximately 45 minutes late. It was a basic screening to make sure you had the required experience and education.

    The interviews, in my opinion, were poorly coordinated. I had to meet with 3 separate people, which in theory would have made sense if they happened at the same time, or even on the same day. Instead I was called into my first interview. they were incredibly accommodating in terms of scheduling times - allowing me to come in before my scheduled shift. The first interview was just an assessment of my skills. The interviewer/manager was very personable and kind. I didn't have a great feeling leaving the interview, but I got a phone call the next day to go in for a second interview.

    At the second interview, I met with the supervisor of the hiring manager. We were to meet at 7:30, but he did not arrive until around 8:00. This should have already put a bad taste in my mouth, but I understand traffic patterns can be inconsistent and things can be outside of our control. The meeting was very informal and not too many questions about me were asked. We basically went over what the gist of the job is and what my responsibilities would entail. I left feeling okay..and then I got a call to go back for a third interview.

    At the third interview I met with the United Way liaison. She was very nice and also very accommodating with my schedule. We discussed my previous experience, education and current goals. We also talked about the role the United Way plays in the community and how the helpline assists in their mission. I left this interview feeling really good. We had an excellent rapport and I thought that she felt the same way.

    After all of the interviews I sent follow up e-mails to thanks the individuals. This was a position I truly saw becoming a career for me, as I had already known a lot about the service from my current job.

    I received ONE follow up e-mail from the United way liaison, thanking me. I did not received any other correspondence from anyone at any point letting me know whether or not I had been the candidate selected. To this day (3 weeks later), I still know nothing and there is absolutely no way to contact any of the individuals involved. It's very disheartening because I invested a lot of time and (parking) money in this because I had a passion for it, only to not hear anything at all. It's a bit insulting and one of the reasons that individuals no longer feel valued by their employers or potential employers. If it is expected that we thank you, you should do the same.

    Interview Questions

    • All of the questions were behavioral assessments or about your previous supervisory experience. There was nothing unexpected or difficult.   Answer Question
See All 1 Interviews

HM Insurance Group Awards & Accolades

Let us know if we're missing any workplace or industry recognition – Add Awards

Work at HM Insurance Group? Share Your Experiences

HM Insurance Group
  • Star
  • Star
  • Star
  • Star
  • Star
Click to Rate