Cover image for Hastings Mutual Insurance Company
Logo
See All Photos

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

Engaged Employer

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

Add a Review

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company Overview

  • www.hastingsmutual.com
  • Hastings, MI
  • 201 to 500 Employees
  • 1885
  • Company - Private
  • Insurance Carriers
  • $100 to $500 million (USD)

Hastings Mutual is committed to offering top quality commercial, farm, and personal insurance products to our customers through a network of independent agents who are experts in their field. In addition, our talented employees are committed to providing excellent service to our ...
Mission: Our mission is to provide insurance products and services at fair prices while maintaining the financial soundness of the company through prudent management. Our mission, guided by the highest ethical standards, is to maintain a growing organization that serves the interests of ...

Company Updates

November 24, 2022
Community
All of us at Hastings Mutual wish all of you a safe and enjoyable Thanksgiving holiday!
Shared image
August 23, 2022
Company News
It's not official until John from our HR team takes the new-hire selfie. Say hello to the latest additions to our Claim and Underwriting areas who joined us this week!
Shared image

What are your colleagues talking about?

Find your private company bowl on Fishbowl, join the hottest conversation with your colleagues anonymously.
Join the Conversation

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company Reviews

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company89
3.7
69%
Recommend to a Friend
76%
Approve of CEO
Hastings Mutual Insurance Company President and CEO  Renee Beauford
Renee Beauford
60 Ratings
Featured Review
5.0
Former Employee

"Take the negative reviews with a large grain of salt"

Dec 27, 2022 - Insurance Professional
Recommends
Positive Outlook
Approves of CEO

Pros

The people at HMIC are wonderful, leaders and non-leaders alike and the company is financially strong. Benefits, especially the 401k match and profit-sharing bonuses are on the better end compared to

Cons

Other reviews mention the pay. It's not that HMIC doesn't pay well, it's that your raises or potential for higher earnings over time won't be anything significant, which is usually why people leave.

Advice to Management

Review the raise and career progression structures to avoid people from stagnating in their positions. Other than that, keep up the great work!
See All 96 Reviews

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company Photos

+ Add Photo
Hastings Mutual Insurance Company photo of: MISSING VALUEHastings Mutual Insurance Company photo of: MISSING VALUEHastings Mutual Insurance Company photo of: MISSING VALUEHastings Mutual Insurance Company photo of: MISSING VALUEHastings Mutual Insurance Company photo of: MISSING VALUEHastings Mutual Insurance Company photo of: MISSING VALUEHastings Mutual Insurance Company photo of: MISSING VALUE

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company Interviews

Experience
Positive37%
Negative42%
Neutral21%
Getting an Interview
Applied online65%
Employee Referral24%
Recruiter6%
Difficulty
2.7
Average
HardAverageEasy

  1. Commercial Lines Underwriting Assistant Interview

    Anonymous Employee in United States
    Accepted Offer
    Neutral Experience
    Average Interview

    Interview

    Three interviews over a few weeks. First with HR, the larger department and finally with department heads. Interviewed with approximately 7 people over 3 weeks. No phone interview offered at the time of hiring.
    Interview

    How did you handle a difficult coworker.

    Answer Question

See All 19 interviews

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company Awards & Accolades

  • Super Regional Property / Casualty InsurerDemotech Inc.2022
  • 2022 US CIO 100CIOReview Magazine2022
  • 2021 Analytics 50Drexel University’s LeBow College of Business2021
  • West Michigan's Best and Brightest Companies to Work ForThe Best and Brightest2021
  • West Michigan's Best and Brightest Companies to Work ForThe Best and Brightest2020

Popular Careers with Hastings Mutual Insurance Company Job Seekers

JobsSalariesInterviews

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company FAQ

(25 Questions)

All answers shown come directly from Hastings Mutual Insurance Company Reviews and are not edited or altered.

See questions about:

What are perks and other benefits like at Hastings Mutual Insurance Company?

...Same benefits and more technically advanced insurance carrier....

November 22, 2022

Read more

See 7 more answers

People Also Ask about Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

To get a job at Hastings Mutual Insurance Company, browse currently open positions and apply for a job near you. Once you get a positive response, make sure to find out about the interview process at Hastings Mutual Insurance Company and prepare for tough questions.

Work at Hastings Mutual Insurance Company? Share Your Experiences

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company logo

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

or

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company Locations

  • Hastings, MI
    3.3
See All Locations
Connect with Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

Follow Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

Facebook
Twitter

Glassdoor gives you an inside look at what it's like to work at Hastings Mutual Insurance Company, including salaries, reviews, office photos, and more. This is the Hastings Mutual Insurance Company company profile. All content is posted anonymously by employees working at Hastings Mutual Insurance Company.