Cover image for BenefitMall
Logo

BenefitMall

Engaged Employer

BenefitMall

Add a Review

BenefitMall Employee Reviews about "manager"

3.7

65% would recommend to a friend

(54 total reviews)

Scott Kirksey

83% approve of CEO

Ratings by category

4.1

Diversity & Inclusion

3.8

Culture & Values

3.7

Work/Life Balance

3.5

Senior Management

3.4

Compensation and Benefits

3.3

Career Opportunities

Ratings distribution

5 stars

23%

4 stars

20%

3 stars

15%

2 stars

15%

1 star

27%

What are your colleagues talking about?

Find your exclusive Company Bowl™ on Community. Join the hottest conversation with your colleagues anonymously.
Join the Conversation

Top Review Highlights by Sentiment

Excerpts from user reviews, not authored by Glassdoor

Pros
Cons
  • "Poor management(in 38 reviews)
  • "Benefits are horrible.(in 16 reviews)
  • "Upper Management is abusive with no knowledge of laws.(in 15 reviews)
  • "Most of what is said verbally is wrong but it's your word against your manager's and the manager always wins.(in 14 reviews)
  • "4. there's no training to update your skills, IT is fast moving so if you don't update your employee and they decide to stay in the company longer(in 8 reviews)

Ratings by Demographics

Want more options?

This rating reflects the overall rating of BenefitMall and is not affected by filters.

Verify your email to use filters. Having problems? Resend email

Found 54 of over 330 reviews

Updated Nov 14, 2023

Reviews about "manager"

Return to all Reviews
54
    1. 1.0
      Jul 1, 2015
      Anonymous Employee
      Current Employee
      Recommend
      CEO Approval
      Business Outlook

      Pros

      Job duties are what I love. I enjoy what I do as long as I don't have to deal with a few in my area. Pay is good and extra perks are great too.

      Cons

      1. Hard to work for a manager who is in it for themselves. Hard to work for a dumb manager and a manager that doesn't listen or care what good of a job you've done. Only looks at the small errors you make 5% of the time. 2. Poor poor communication. Most of what is said verbally is wrong but it's your word against your manager's and the manager always wins. Noone ever checks with the worker bees to get their side or opinions. 3. Work is passed down to us and the manager gets alllllllllllll the credit as if they did the work. Brags about how she even did the research and found the problem when she couldn't even tell you what the problem was in the first place. 4. Manager just lies lies lies lies liess lies lies lies liess lies lies lies lies and never takes up for her department on anything. 5. Manager always ready to point the finger at someone else when it's really her error or her bad instructions. 6. People hired to do one thing (high level) to end up doing data entry and nothing close to what our degree is. 7. Upper management stays on their side of the building so they have no clue what or how we are all suffering. Never see how we are working our butt off while our manager is out running errands for 2 hours or on personal calls all day. 8. I could go on and on and on but I think yall get my point.

      11
      1. 2.0
        Apr 19, 2011
        Former Employee
        Recommend
        CEO Approval
        Business Outlook

        Pros

        This company had one of the best training directors / departments that I have had the pleasure of experiencing. They need to use it more often!!

        Cons

        Several Sr. Managers are very disrespectful and degrading to their employees. There is no place for yelling within the workplace. Overall, it was an unhealthy, toxic environment.

        6
      2. Join the BenefitMall team
        See Our Latest Jobs
        1. 1.0
          Jun 28, 2017
          District Manager
          Current Employee
          Somerset, NJ
          Recommend
          CEO Approval
          Business Outlook

          Pros

          None that I can think of.

          Cons

          Worst company I have ever worked for. They hire successful reps from the big payroll companies and provide very little training or support. Everyone works from a home office which is very isolated. I was told by my direct manager that there is no quota for the first 90 days. Then he gave me a 30 and 60 day review at the same time, which made no sense to me. He put in my 60 day review that if I did not sell something in the next 30 days I would be terminated. I don't know how that was possible since I did not even have a quota. My supervisor and his boss were constant no shows for training meetings they set with me. Just would not show up and then have a lame excuse as to why not. My boss is constantly trying to cover up for lack of training me. He actually said 'Get a new job and I'll be a great referral for you. Just don't throw me under the bus'. Who thinks like that? Now the VP is involved and she is micromanaging me and that does not work. The whole experience has been a nightmare. The company seems to have a cancer running through it.

          11

          Thank you for your feedback. It is important to provide consistent feedback to your manager with concerns about your training. Managers can provide additional training and support to help you reach your goals. BenefitMall offers its employees varied training tools to ensure their success.

          1. 3.0
            Sep 10, 2020
            Decline to Say
            Former Employee, more than 1 year
            Recommend
            CEO Approval
            Business Outlook

            Pros

            Benefits & Flexibility Co-workers become your family Company makes great utilization of technology internally

            Cons

            No room for growth and managers do not develop their teams Management is under-trained and not always capable Management does not understand leader versus boss mentality Poor communication from top down Employees are promoted even when not qualified Upper management does not hold anyone accountable

            Thank you for taking the time to provide a thoughtful and constructive review. We appreciate the insight you provide from your experience. If you have anything specific you would like to share, we would like to hear it - you can contact Human Resources directly.

            1. 5.0
              Jul 9, 2014
              Anonymous
              Current Employee, more than 1 year
              Recommend
              CEO Approval
              Business Outlook

              Pros

              The internal growth is abundant across all departments and there is a great company culture. My manager also has a vested interest in her team and strives for us to succeed. The company is flexible and will do whatever they can to support their employees.

              Cons

              The new health plan is a challenge for some employees and there should be another option for people to opt into using.

              3
              1. 5.0
                Feb 27, 2020
                Carrier Information Analyst
                Current Contractor, less than 1 year
                Dallas, TX
                Recommend
                CEO Approval
                Business Outlook

                Pros

                1. Team are super nice and my manager is awesome 2. Moderate work pace 3. Continuing training program

                Cons

                Everything is perfect, so far so good.

                Thank you for your review and we are glad you have had a positive experience! We have invested in our training program to become even more robust and accessible, and I am glad to hear it is helpful. Thank you for your feedback.

                1. 4.0
                  Mar 21, 2018
                  Anonymous Employee
                  Current Employee, more than 1 year
                  Recommend
                  CEO Approval
                  Business Outlook

                  Pros

                  Big Company moves with change like a Small company is refreshing coming. Approvals for items are almost the small hour they are requested. Constant investment in to process, people, and product. Great Compensation Plan that rewards performance, simple to understand, and a stable distribution channel. Best I've seen in the Payroll industry. Big Sales Territories with training tools available internally and via manager.

                  Cons

                  Not as big as ADP or Paychex, so name recognition is not as strong.

                  Thank you for taking the time to confirm we are heading in the right direction. Please continue to provide feedback during your career journey at BenefitMall.

                  1. 1.0
                    Nov 20, 2016
                    Broker Sales Representative
                    Current Employee, more than 5 years
                    Livingston, NJ
                    Recommend
                    CEO Approval
                    Business Outlook

                    Pros

                    Making connections / contacts with other brokers (clients) and a variety of health insurance carriers so you can use those contacts. Networking will get you ahead in your career

                    Cons

                    It seems that if you are 'friends' with your manager or director, that you will succeed. Being a hard worker who does their work and more won't help you keep your job. Office is full of people who don't do their work. Often passing it on to someone beneath them in the position ladder So much gossip going on- reminds me of being at school Make sure you can prove you did your work because your word will not be trusted. People throw others under the bus all the time. You must prove yourself by saving everything Several of my coworkers are drug addicts and alcoholics. One of my coworkers passed out in a meeting with the entire office present. My manager came into my cubicle, asking if I was the one who smelled of alcohol. No. I don't drink. I pointed to the coworker who passed out in the meeting. And she didn't do anything about it. I've spoke to my manager several times of this coworker passing out in his cubicle. Amazingly, he is still there. He got someone fired when he was harassing my coworker over texts on a weekend (after office hours). When her spouse asked him to stop harassing her or he would speak to him face to face to talk about what he's doing - he went right to manager that Monday. And she got let go because he claimed it was a threat. It wasn't. I saw the texts. Doesn't matter that she was well liked by all her clients. Did all her work. Did extra work that no one wanted to do. Perfect example of how Benefitmall is

                    8
                  Viewing 1 - 10 of 54 Reviews
                  </>Embed

                  Popular Careers with BenefitMall Job Seekers

                  JobsSalariesInterviews

                  Popular Conversations

                  Interview Tips

                  Feel free to post any interview questions you might be asked and I’ll help you compose an effective response :)

                  RFP Coordinator

                  I have a 5 year gap in my work history due to an illness. How do I explain this? I can't lie, SSD is on my background check as a previous employer. I am on it and looking to re-enter the job market and get off of it, but I understand it is a reason for employers to pause in hiring me.

                  1
                  3 Comments

                  Senior Associate

                  How do you interview for a position when you are under-qualified based on seniority but not based on skills? I currently serve as a senior associate for a reputable consulting firm, and I have an interview for an associate director position. However, I am just shy of the minimum YOE requirement included on the job application and relatively young (though I meet all of the other requirements). Any advice on convincing the hiring manager I am ready for a mid-level role?

                  5
                  0 Comments

                  EY

                  Had 4 behavioral interviews for a position last week. Last Friday (which was the last of the four interviews), the interviewer spent most of the interview selling me on the job and didn't ask me any questions. She ended the interview by saying she thinks I am confident and would be a great fit for the role. I took this as a good sign but giving it's 2023 you never truly know. Has anyone ever had an interviewer do something similar and not gotten the job?

                  5
                  7 Comments

                  Glassdoor has 330 BenefitMall reviews submitted anonymously by BenefitMall employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if BenefitMall is right for you.