Only work here if it is your option - Anonymous employee Sheeley Employee Review

1.0
Feb 18, 2021
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Decent cloud based integration meaning you can work anywhere as long as you had the internet. Pay is comparable to other firms in the industry if not better than some depending on experience. If you are a favored associate, you might get flown on a private chartered plane to the partner's holiday home in Martha's Vineyard for the weekend.

Cons

Horrible place to work top-to-bottom. For starters, like most firms it is supposedly organized as a partnership, by inference means the multitude of partners should have a say in how the firm operates. In actuality, this firm operates with one person in charge where the "partners" tacitly agree with the chief and are unwilling to voice concerns or back subordinates or even each other. Partners are themselves put into tiers where clearly there is disparity in how one is treated unless you are one of the "good-old-boys" willing to drink hard/do as the chief says. The billable hours targets in normal non-covid times are high but ludicrous during a pandemic when the majority of billable hours from an insurance defense shop comes from in-person court appearances. The firm is also very top-heavy with partners outnumbering associates, who in turn outnumber the support staff. Associates are treated poorly or as glorified paralegals (they nominally have one paralegal) where the associates are not coached/taught anything substantively and the partners have the distinct habit of contradicting each other and crucially claiming that their way is the right way and must be applied to all cases in the firm. The associate turnover is high with the majority of associates working for the firm less than a year. Support staff are treated poorly. The firm received government loans during covid and then proceeded to "furlough" and fire staff at the first opportunity. Staff faced repercussions for having to shelter-at-home due to potential covid-risk. During the pandemic and when folks were required to be in the office, several persons in the firm tested positive for covid and the leadership of the firm did nothing to address the issue. Associates and staff were still expected to come into the office.

Explore other reviews about Sheeley

5.0
Jan 7, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The firm stands out for providing early in-court opportunities—you’re trusted with substantive responsibilities like handling conferences, depositions, and even trial work early in your career, which really accelerates your development as a litigator. Unlike some firms where it takes years to get real courtroom exposure, here you’re encouraged to step up and take ownership right away. The mentorship is also a huge plus. Senior attorneys are approachable and genuinely invested in helping associates grow. They offer clear guidance, actionable feedback, and plenty of opportunities to ask questions or brainstorm strategies. It’s a collaborative and supportive environment where you feel like your contributions matter, even as a junior team member. If you're looking for a firm that prioritizes professional growth, meaningful litigation experience, and a strong sense of teamwork, Sheeley is a fantastic choice.

Cons

The firm is a fast-paced and dynamic place to work, especially during high-stakes cases or trial preparation. While the workload can be demanding at times, it’s a reflection of the firm’s dedication to delivering exceptional results for clients. For those who are eager to learn and grow, this environment provides invaluable opportunities to build skills and confidence quickly.

3.0
Jan 21, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Solid experience and nice people

Cons

Inconsistent management and lack of support staff

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All