How much does a Claims Supervisor make?

Updated Nov 30, 2023

Experience

Industry

Total Pay Range
$65K - $106K/yr
Base Pay
$60K - $97K/yr
Additional Pay
$5K - $8K/yr

$83K

/yr
$65K$106K
Most Likely Range

The estimated total pay for a Claims Supervisor is $82,518 per year in the United States area, with an average salary of $76,455 per year. These numbers represent the median, which is the midpoint of the ranges from our proprietary Total Pay Estimate model and based on salaries collected from our users. The estimated additional pay is $6,064 per year. Additional pay could include cash bonus, commission, tips, and profit sharing. The "Most Likely Range" represents values that exist within the 25th and 75th percentile of all pay data available for this role.

How accurate is this most likely Total Pay range (base + additional) of $65K-$106K/yr?

Top Paying Companies

For a Claims Supervisor in United States

Below is the total pay for the top 10 highest paying companies for a Claims Supervisor in United States. Employers include ESIS (PA), CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer and Chubb.

1
ESIS (PA)
ESIS (PA)
$105,936/yr
9 open jobs
3
Chubb
$103,713/yr
See pay for all companies for a Claims Supervisor in United StatesView data as table

Top Paying Companies

For Claims Supervisor in United States

1ESIS (PA)$105,936
2CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer$104,770
3Chubb$103,713
4Erie Insurance Group$98,870
5Progressive Insurance$97,906
6Amica Insurance$96,965
7Farmers Insurance Group$96,518
8MetLife$95,831
9Health Care Service Corporation$93,903
10Mercury Insurance Company$93,627

What are total pay estimates for a Claims Supervisor at different companies?

or
Sort:
Company
Jobs
Total Pay Range
GEICO
2.8
Claims SupervisorSee 186 salaries from all locations

$87,273

 / yr
Progressive Insurance
3.8
Claims SupervisorSee 166 salaries from all locations

$97,906

 / yr
Farmers Insurance Group
3.2
Claims SupervisorSee 77 salaries from all locations

$96,518

 / yr
Walmart
3.4
Claims SupervisorSee 62 salaries from all locations

$35

 / hr
GEICO
2.6
Claims SupervisorSee 24 salaries from all locations

$87,273

 / yr
Gallagher
3.6
Claims SupervisorSee 24 salaries from all locations

$89,588

 / yr
UnitedHealth Group
3.7
Claims SupervisorSee 23 salaries from all locations

$76,356

 / yr

Is this salary info helpful?

Let’s pay it forward! The Glassdoor community relies on people like you to share accurate salary info to promote fair compensation everywhere

Share Salary Anonymously
Amica Insurance
3.6
Claims SupervisorSee 23 salaries from all locations

$96,965

 / yr
Mercury Insurance Company
3.6
Claims SupervisorSee 17 salaries from all locations

$93,627

 / yr
Chubb
3.7
Claims SupervisorSee 15 salaries from all locations

$103,713

 / yr
CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer
3.7
Claims SupervisorSee 15 salaries from all locations

$104,770

 / yr
CorVel
3.2
Claims SupervisorSee 13 salaries from all locations

$82,947

 / yr
AmTrust Financial
3.3
Claims SupervisorSee 12 salaries from all locations

$93,626

 / yr
Centene
3.7
Claims SupervisorSee 12 salaries from all locations

$80,502

 / yr
Progressive Insurance
3.8
Claim SupervisorSee 10 salaries from all locations

$91,606

 / yr
UnitedHealthCare
3.6
Claims SupervisorSee 10 salaries from all locations

$73,105

 / yr
Kemper
3.6
Claims SupervisorSee 9 salaries from all locations

$87,057

 / yr
The Cigna Group
3.5
Claims SupervisorSee 9 salaries from all locations

$79,358

 / yr
Sedgwick
3.3
Claims SupervisorSee 8 salaries from all locations

$85,874

 / yr
Farmers Insurance Group
3.2
Claim SupervisorSee 8 salaries from all locations

$89,968

 / yr
Download as data table

Claims Supervisor Salaries

Job TitleSalary
GEICO Claims Supervisor salaries - 186 salaries reported$87,273/yr
Progressive Insurance Claims Supervisor salaries - 166 salaries reported$97,906/yr
Farmers Insurance Group Claims Supervisor salaries - 77 salaries reported$96,518/yr
Walmart Claims Supervisor salaries - 62 salaries reported$35/hr
GEICO Claims Supervisor salaries - 24 salaries reported$87,273/yr
Gallagher Claims Supervisor salaries - 24 salaries reported$89,588/yr
UnitedHealth Group Claims Supervisor salaries - 23 salaries reported$76,356/yr
Amica Insurance Claims Supervisor salaries - 23 salaries reported$96,965/yr
Mercury Insurance Company Claims Supervisor salaries - 17 salaries reported$93,627/yr
Chubb Claims Supervisor salaries - 15 salaries reported$103,713/yr
CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer Claims Supervisor salaries - 15 salaries reported$104,770/yr
CorVel Claims Supervisor salaries - 13 salaries reported$82,947/yr
AmTrust Financial Claims Supervisor salaries - 12 salaries reported$93,626/yr
Centene Claims Supervisor salaries - 12 salaries reported$80,502/yr
Progressive Insurance Claim Supervisor salaries - 10 salaries reported$91,606/yr
UnitedHealthCare Claims Supervisor salaries - 10 salaries reported$73,105/yr
Kemper Claims Supervisor salaries - 9 salaries reported$87,057/yr
The Cigna Group Claims Supervisor salaries - 9 salaries reported$79,358/yr
Sedgwick Claims Supervisor salaries - 8 salaries reported$85,874/yr
Farmers Insurance Group Claim Supervisor salaries - 8 salaries reported$89,968/yr
Viewing 1 - 20 of 420

Top Paying Industries

For a Claims Supervisor in United States

The top 5 paying industries for a Claims Supervisor in United States are Insurance with a median total pay of $90,758, Legal with a median total pay of $83,617, Information Technology with a median total pay of $82,621, Healthcare with a median total pay of $75,662, and Financial Services with a median total pay of $75,489.

IndustryTotal PayTotal Pay Insight
  • InsuranceInsurance$90,758

    4% Higher than other industries

  • LegalLegal$83,617

    5% Lower than other industries

  • Information TechnologyInformation Technology$82,621

    6% Lower than other industries

  • HealthcareHealthcare$75,662

    16% Lower than other industries

  • Financial ServicesFinancial Services$75,489

    16% Lower than other industries

Insurance

Top paying companies in Insurance for Claims Supervisor are ESIS (PA), CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer, and Chubb.

ESIS (PA)ESIS (PA)$105,936/yr
ChubbChubb$103,713/yr

Glassdoor Economist Pay Overview

What is the pay outlook for Finance & Accounting?

Jobs in finance and accounting are expected to see continued demand, with employment growth linked to the health of the broader economy. These jobs will continue to offer above average pay but usually require higher education or certification to enter the field. While automation will replace many common tasks, it is not expected to reduce the need for these employees; it will instead allow them to focus on core soft skills like advising clients and analyzing trends.

Claims Supervisor pay FAQ

The average salary for a Claims Supervisor is $82,518 per year in United States. Salaries estimates are based on 1203 salaries submitted anonymously to Glassdoor by a Claims Supervisor employees in United States.

The highest salary for a Claims Supervisor in United States is $105,571 per year.

The lowest salary for a Claims Supervisor in United States is $64,758 per year.

If you are thinking of becoming a Claims Supervisor or planning the next step in your career, find details about the role, the career path and salary trajectory of a Claims Supervisor.

Salaries

 > 

claims supervisor