The typical Sheetz Store Manager salary is $45,749. Store Manager salaries at Sheetz can range from $35,062 - $100,000. This estimate is based upon 89 Sheetz Store Manager salary report(s) provided by employees or estimated based upon statistical methods. When factoring in bonuses and additional compensation, a Store Manager at Sheetz can expect to make an average total pay of $84,940 . See all Store Manager salaries to learn how this stacks up in the market.