Where reputation no longer matters - Engineering Checkatrade Employee Review

1.0
Nov 10, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

They provide a strong benefits package, but job security reduces its value. Typically, competitive salaries.

Cons

I am dismayed to have observed ineffective, toxic, inexperienced, and power-hungry senior management and leadership undermine the brand reputation and working culture of this formerly reputable company, unfairly impacting the livelihoods of dedicated employees. When I started at Checkatrade, it was a welcoming workplace, albeit not without flaws. The people made it great. However, a rapid and detrimental culture shift occurred due to misguided promotions within the Engineering team. Bullying, unfair performance practices, inconsistent bonuses, unrealistic delivery commitments, indecisive priorities, non-technical leaders in engineering, top-down workload management, an authoritarian approach to development, and overcommitted, misaligned roadmaps created a perfect storm. Initially, there was hope as new engineering leadership emerged with CTO Mal Minhas, who initially made a positive impression on most of the engineering team. However, this optimism was short-lived. Mal Minhas has demonstrated poor leadership by surrounding himself with unqualified and culturally incompatible direct reports, many of whom have faced multiple formal complaints to HR that have had no repercussions. Mal Minhas adopts a non-collaborative approach to developing technical strategies, lacks essential people skills (often choosing to work in the kitchen rather than with the engineers), and seems to support half-baked ideas by referencing blogs as his source of knowledge. His average tenure of less than 2 years in any job over the last 10 years raises questions about his suitability as a leader and his commitment to the company and its people. Expecting support from HR? You might have better luck seeking sympathy from Elon Musk. The history of no repercussions for managers with logged complaints, often resulting in promotions, reflects a flaky approach. Despite raising a complaint, I experienced HR's sensitivity, but the promised actions regarding another senior manager were never followed up, which led to additional discrimination. In the additional complaint of discrimination, I was informed that it had been 'noted' and wouldn't be investigated since I was leaving. CPO John Frith, often credited as employee number two, needs to consider change. Dismissing bad Glassdoor reviews as the result of 'disgruntled ex-employees' shows a complete disregard for understanding why these individuals left and felt compelled to warn others. Maybe it's not them, John; it's Checkatrade! Lastly, if you value working for a company that takes data protection seriously, seek alternatives. Critical failures of data handling, storage, and access the company has not fixed issues raised to them this year. Should HR choose to try and spin this review to your cookie cutter “we do our best, sorry you feel this way, please contact us” response, save it. It’s best you leave it for the ICO to determine if you are actually doing your best. Checkatrade’s engineering department is in a worse state than it’s ever been and I don’t think with a single ounce of optimism that I have, that it will get better. Those now in charge are more toxic than the last lot that were cleared out.

avatar
Checkatrade Response
2y
Many thanks for taking the time to leave us your review. It’s great to see that you recognised our strong benefits package and competitive salaries. With the cons and advice to management points you have stated, from a HR standpoint, we can confirm that we take immediate action and provide support to all our people. We take a zero-tolerance approach to bullying and will immediately investigate all allegations, complaints and grievances which are raised with us, and reach appropriate resolutions and outcomes as a result. Data protection is also taken extremely seriously at Checkatrade – the safety of our customer and employee data is our absolute priority and the working practices with which we use data adhere to strict industry standards and guidelines. We are on an exciting journey of accelerated growth and transformation, which includes new leadership, a new mission, and new company values. We’re also taking a new architecture direction too – which includes huge technical changes to our internal systems and processes. After 25 years, the ongoing success of Checkatrade offers many long-term job opportunities for exceptional talented people to thrive. However, as with any business, it is necessary to continuously review that we have the right structures in place to facilitate our growth, which means having the right the people in the right roles. If you would like to discuss your detailed comments regarding individual members of our Leadership Team in more detail, we encourage you to contact our Chief People Officer, John Frith directly on john.frith@checkatrade.com. We wish you luck in your next role.

Explore other reviews about Checkatrade

2.0
May 9, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Colleagues of the highest calibre Decent bonus

Cons

I genuinely want this business to succeed, which is probably why some of the recent decisions have been difficult to watch unfold. At times, it can feel like leadership is building the plane while flying it - which, to be fair, is not uncommon in fast-moving companies, but it does create uncertainty for the people trying to keep everything running day to day. The steady stream of disappearing colleagues has also had an impact on morale. When teams become smaller but workloads stay the same (or grow), burnout becomes a very real risk. And while AI is undoubtedly useful, it’s still not a substitute for experienced people, collaboration, and institutional knowledge. I don’t need this business to act like we’re one big family. But I do want clarity, respect, and the ability to do good work in a healthy environment. Respect and psychological safety are two things not enjoyed at Checkatrade currently, at least as far as I can gather from those I’ve spoken to.

11
1.0
May 21, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Supportive Team members and that's it

Cons

What can I say, since joining it has been downhill. No proper onboarding interms of the team process and ops. One day induction which was a high level concept of the company. Every month the goal post changed, strategy changes, wanting us to adapt (which is acceptable in a scale up ) but when it happens all the time, everyone was demotivated. Staff, manager shuffles without proper reasoning. Incompetent managers who doesn't have skills in the area of operations but working just by pure influence and internal politics. Sick leaves are unpaid for they deduct salary but pay SSP. HR is not very supportive for staff, they behave like they have to save the company. Even deduct pay after leaving company and asks you to pay to the comlaysaying they overpaid. Their HR systems are completely odd. I would not recommend this company to anyone. So many team members frustrated and stating there without an option. If I have an option I would give minus stars for this company.

4
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All