PolicyMe reviews

4.3

80% would recommend to a friend

(39 total reviews)

Andrew Ostro

97% approve of CEO

79% positive business outlook

PolicyMe has an employee rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars, based on 39 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an excellent working experience there. The PolicyMe employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Information Technology industry (3.9 stars).

Reviews by job title

39 reviews
3.0
Oct 31, 2025

Bizarre hiring practices

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Active employer branding presence online

Cons

Minimal follow-up or feedback for candidates HR culture appears more focused on social media than execution Leadership priorities feel misaligned with core recruiting needs

avatar
PolicyMe Response
7mo
We’re sorry to hear that this was your experience. While we value a strong employer brand, we know it’s equally important to follow through with clear and timely communication. Your feedback is appreciated and will help us continue to improve how we engage with candidates.
4.0
Jun 4, 2025

Great place

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great people and friendly enviornment.

Cons

Could be more room for growth, but overall good.

avatar
PolicyMe Response
12mo
Glad you had an overall positive experience, thank you so much for the review!
2.0
Apr 5, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

1.Friendly Cofounders, CEO 2.Good stock options. 3.Company events. 4.Friendly people. 5.CEO gives monthly company report which keeps every employee on the same page. 6.Company benefits.

Cons

1.Unrealistic expectations, goals set by Managers based on their experience. If manager with 12 +years of experience can fix the issue in 1 hour does not mean to expect the same by other devs. Because every dev is different with varied experience. Hires very less developers , but expects to complete 3 to 4 task in a day which cannot be pushed to next day. Hence increasing stress and anxiety in dev even after working day and night. Task deadlines/ story points are allocated hourly basis during sprint planning. Does not follow daily basis sprint . 2.If you failed to deliver one task due to the requirements change , you will be judged for the entire year on the same thing no matter how well you perform later. Due to this you might end up questioning /doubting your own abilities and skills. 3.Mental health discussions in the company doesn't have any value especially for developers. 4. Unlimited sick leaves has no meaning. If developers takes sick leaves you will see HR questioning you even though you were sick. And expects to change it to paid leaves. 5.Lack of communication, support from the coworkers(developers) of same team because there is no time to breath and every developer is piled up with lot of tasks for the day and has no time to answer or help their own team member/coworker. When asked for help from the coworker, asks to wait for the entire day which makes you to ask for help from other team. 6. Work from anywhere option is not for everyone in the company(HR and some other roles get to work from anywhere). 7. Any concerns raised will be just heard but later ignored.

avatar
PolicyMe Response
3y
I'm sorry to hear that this has been your experience at PolicyMe and I want to thank you for your feedback. As a rapidly growing company we are moving fast and recognize that there are periods that are more challenging than others. We are a company that wants to have a lasting impact in the insurance industry and acknowledge that creating change in a centuries-old industry isn't easy. We are constantly pushing ourselves to create the best products and experiences for our customers. It's unfortunate that you didn't feel supported, as collaboration is one of our company's values and we pride ourselves on building together. As you mention, we really do have an awesome team, focus on offering as much transparency as possible, and are doing our best to listen to feedback, to offer a great set of benefits for our people (e.g., in-person events, a comprehensive benefits plan, flexibility and more). We appreciate your thoughts and wish you the best of luck in your next opportunity.
Viewing 1 - 3 of 39 Reviews

Glassdoor has 42 PolicyMe reviews submitted anonymously by PolicyMe employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if PolicyMe is right for you.