Best paying job, but worst employee relations/treatment ever. - Supervisor Sheetz Employee Review

2.0
Aug 15, 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Their pay is the highest I've seen compared to may jobs. They also offer great benefits with medical/dental /vision, tuition reimbursement and 401K

Cons

If you don't kiss "Butt" then they will nit pick at everything you do. You will most likely get stuck working a shift you don't want. If you are a shift supervisor, plan to work harder that the assistants and store manager. Also upper management never does anything wrong.

Explore other reviews about Sheetz

5.0
Mar 14, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-scheduled breaks -full time while still having three days off a week -set rotating schedule -pto and bonuses after the first month or two -overall decent atmosphere but could be different for other places -pretty forgiving points system -comprehensive training program makes it a lot easier to jump into things if you are new -VERY competitive pay and benefits -employee discounts and stock

Cons

-can be a bit strict about procedures but that is also a good thing -can have shift inequality -depending on location and crew size, it can be overwhelming at first -for this position specifically, switching between stores and crews who have different expectations, cultures, and rules can be a bit difficult to get used to at first

avatar
Sheetz Response
2mo
So glad to hear you’re enjoying the perkz and schedule! Thanks for the feedback and being a part of our Sheetz work fam.
3.0
Apr 21, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-pay and benefits are good, -flexibility with schedule. -bonus every quarter based on customer satisfaction -(based on store) good management

Cons

-constant changes that don't make sense -QA can decide a new rule with no notice.(I support this if it leads to safer food, or better quality in the way we do things) -Constant mass producing of new stores, leeching off the yearly bonus we used to get every year. -Its a uphill battle to get a terrible employee out of the store, you would think its a union job with how hard it is. -(based on store) some locations with down right sacrifice the rest of the store to get a bonus based on one metric (and only management gets said bonus) , everything is a metric game. AHOD trumps all, everything else is secondary for some awful reason

avatar
Sheetz Response
1mo
Thank you for your feedback! We have passed this along to our larger team, and also encourage you to reach out to Employee Relations about any other concerns: 1-800-280-4357.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All