Company Skips Over the Right People for the Job and Doesn't Promote from within... - Customer Service Specialist Sherwin-Williams Employee Review

3.0
Jul 14, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The training at SW is great, but the sales managers are under a lot of duress and are now have to make outside sales calls (which is what they have reps for), taking them out of a store which is already understaffed. The compensation is good, they have several promotions and partnerships with other companies for discounts. The health insurance was okay, not great, but at least they do offer it (with employee subsidies, i.e., you pay part, they pay part).

Cons

The promotion policies are DISMAL. They say they promote 90-something percent from within, but I'll tell you what that is. They have an MTP (manager trainee program) position that they create for recent college grads. If you're a full-time employee in the store and you know the customers and you apply for associate manager, you'll be passed over in favor of someone they've placed in the MTP "position" and they will then promote that person "from within" as an associate manager. They hire too many MTPs per year and thus, you'll never have a chance to move up if you don't have a degree. If it tells you anything about the company, I chose to pursue a degree after I'd been there for 3 years. I was told I was the best candidate for the job but that they "had to pass me over because you don't have a bachelor's degree". This was by my district manager. I attained my bachelors degree but no longer work for them and will not reapply to become an MTP and follow their convoluted system. Morale is bad and top management in some divisions and districts can't even read the reports.

Explore other reviews about Sherwin-Williams

5.0
Apr 30, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great Culture and career growth oppurtunities!

Cons

There was no cons with my experience.

2.0
Jun 2, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Leadership training, flexible schedule if your store has the necessary staffing, 401k match

Cons

If you don't have staffing then you are required to work weekends consistently, Sales calls requirements keep getting higher and higher, incompetent corporate leadership. Pay is based on 44 hours worked weekly for assistants(48 for Store managers; leaves room for less work/life balance

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All