Pros
As somebody who has been in the industry at multiple carriers, if someone has something poor to say about Progressive it is because they do not know any different or they enjoy complaining. Work at Progressive and then you will spend the rest of your career comparing everything to it. The stability, culture, and people are second to none. A true culture that breeds pride, respect, and integrity in what you do. Everyone at Progressive seems proud to be there, If they aren't, they truly don't know how lucky they are. I didn't realize it at the time. 2 major carriers later, and I realize how good I had it.
Cons
Pay is low compared to market. But the gainshare bonus is second to none and the stability / benefits are good enough to make the lower market rate justified. In sum, while the base pay is low, total comp once you factor in stellar benefits and gainshare make it good. However, some would still prefer the higher market rate.