Look Elsewhere ~ Toxic and Terrible - Senior Claims Adjuster Progressive Insurance Employee Review

2.0
Jun 13, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Decent salary range for positions, Gainshare bonus that vests in December annually.

Cons

incredibly bad leadership; is very definition of toxic corporate culture. To give some company history, Progressive Home Insurance used to be an independently owned company named American Strategic Insurance. Progressive bought them so they could enter the Property side of the business as they used to be Auto only. American Strategic Insurance was a pretty good company - not perfect and definitely had challenges - but they treated their employees really well, offered great benefits, and competitive salaries, and overall had positive leadership and good people. Over the few years after Progressive phased out the original leaders, the company took a really bad turn. Benefits were cut significantly, raises during the economic downturns have been non-existent even for cost of living. And the only people to receive promotions did so with complete lack of skill / knowledge and began receiving promotions based entirely on their prior friendships and mentorships. I was told multiple times that the candidates who are promoted are 95% determined before they begin accepting applicants. The company approach to the work was, finish your work and do it well and you will be rewarded, to post-Progressive approach. I can honestly state that working with Progressive has been the worst decision of my past decade. All of the most talented people have left in the past 5 years with more always looking for something else all the time. They routinely bring in green employees and replace adequate quality training with robotic templates to cut / paste into their files to fluff them up. The insureds often bear the price. Employees that quit are sometimes not replaced and the work gets "bulk reassigned" so that everyone is over capacity most of the time. The main methodology of leadership is to institute new policies - often to the employees' detriment - solely for the sake of validating their existence in that role and give an appearance of innovating. And never with positive impacts on performance of quality of work. Corporate toxic.

Explore other reviews about Progressive Insurance

5.0
Jun 25, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great management and work life balance

Cons

Unrealistic expectations Nothing else really

5.0
May 22, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Work from home and flexible scheduling, can slide schedule up to two hours to accommodate appointments, etc.

Cons

Unrealistic claim volume, it ramps up slowly when you're in training and then you start getting so many claims you don't know what to do with them. Customer service is constantly preached, but it's not possible to return voicemails, texts and emails timely while managing 20 claims a day. They keep increasing volume, and you have to spend a minimum of 5 hours a week taking live calls, during which you cannot make any calls out on your own claims, and are required to work each claim you take a call on to it's fullest point, even when they are brand new and unassigned, taking you away from taking action on your own claims that could prevent calls. They are incorporating AI and digital tools that were intended to simplify the process and reduce phone time, but customers are upset and refuse to participate, which means claims are delayed awaiting digital statements, and then need more phone calls anyway. The expectations are outrageous.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All