SF is THE Market Leader for P&C, but the New Agent Contract (AA05) can be very challenging ..... Do Your Homework! - Insurance Sales Agent State Farm Employee Review

4.0
Jul 10, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Agent Compensation is truly uncapped - the harder you work and the more business (and the higher volume you write in ALL lines of business) you write - the more you will make. There is an opportunity to earn a SIGNIFICANT Scorecard Bonus each year. The general public is very familiar with the company, so new agents will have instant credibility and brand name recognition. If you can be a high performer you will be rewarded with trips around the world (Ambassador travel program).

Cons

Summary: For the RIGHT PERSON the Agent opportunity can be everything they would want it to be - but I observed in myself and many other agents that it takes an extraordinary amount of focus, organization, time management, and teamwork, along with the ability to continually invest heavily in your business to be a consistent high producing agent. Details: The AA05 Contact is a GROWTH-BASED compensation plan. SF will guarantee you a base level of P&C commissions, but an additional 3% has to earned / validated every year. This can be extremely challenging based on the market your office is in; or if there any restrictions SF has placed regarding underwriting or rates in your area. Additionally - life events such as the births of children, impaired health or deaths of loved ones, divorce, etc may require time away from the office and may take your 100% attention off of growing the business - which may mean that you will earn less next year than you did this year. The AA05 contract is genius from SF's point of view (because of variable comp you can never relax and be content with your existing book of business), but when it works against you as an agent it can be extremely frustrating! As a side note - I had significant work / life balance issues as an agent. I became divorced during my time in agency, and when I ultimately won full custody of my daughter I ended up resigning from SF Agency a few years later as I found it extremely difficult to be fully vested in growing my agency, and meet my own standards of being a successful father. ALSO - if you are considering becoming an agent, DO YOUR HOMEWORK in regards to average premiums in any particular market area, as premiums can VARY WIDELY from state to state, and even within the same state. If I had my size book of business in SC or WV, instead of NC (where my agency was located) - my annual gross compensation would have likely been $50,000 or more higher! Not everyone wants to live in WV, but the difference in premiums (how commissions are derived) can be significant. Lastly, as an agent you will constantly be dealing with employees - hiring them, training them, firing them, etc. I would say that staffing issues are a universal challenge for most State Farm agents that want / need to perform at a fairly high level. Just know that on the front end!

Explore other reviews about State Farm

5.0
Jun 12, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

State Farm is a very reputable company to work for, and they have a lot of great benefits.

Cons

Like any big corporation, a lot of it is who you know.

3.0
Mar 8, 2018
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

(At the time) Fair pay and predictable bonus structure They were pretty good at covering travel expenses and paying them back quickly Diverse workforce & diversity initiatives Fun and funny coworkers Opportunities for growth Again, this was all four years ago and has likely changed

Cons

(At the time and now, according to other comments) Arrogant to a fault Total lack of innovation & willingness to innovate Odd attachment to the company's past (which prevents progress) High number of veterans (20+ years) who are determined to get that retirement money, and therefore, are resistant to change and technology Heavy reliance on command and control management style Poor decision-making that leads to losses of all kinds

1058
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All