I applied online. The process took 3 weeks. I interviewed at Progressive Insurance (Bohemia, NY) in Oct 2015
Interview
DON'T BOTHER IF YOU ARE OVER 30 YEARS OLD. I am struck dumbfounded. Somehow I was denied the position after rigorous preparation and sticking right to the directions.
My exact reason for not being hired: LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST in the position.
LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST after a complete online application.
LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST after an online pre-assessment consisting of math and customer service question.
LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST after an hour and a half phone interview.
LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST after obtaining documents from old employers for a thorough background check.
LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST after studying the STAR format of answering questions and practicing answers.
LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST after studying and learning about Progressive's history and programs.
LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST after a 2-hour interview with clear examples for every question.
(I wish I had some better explanation than LACK OF MOTIVATIONAL INTEREST, having spent so much time applying)
As I sat in the waiting room, I watched young 20-somethings who just looked like they rolled out of bed and put on a collared shirt dredge in and out of the rooms. I can only reason one of two things:
I was perceived as some kind of overqualified applicant, or I just didn't come off as someone that the hiring manager could control, either way, I did not see anyone other than these workers.
Unfortunately, I am sure that the advertised position will still be hiring for several months.
Interview questions [1]
Question 1
Name a time that you improved upon a process in your past jobs. Everything is in STAR format, however, this is most likely the question that got me.
I applied online. I interviewed at Progressive Insurance in Jun 2026
Interview
I have not completed the process yet but, first was an online assessment, then if you 'pass' you are moved on to a HireVue video interview which takes about 30 minutes with 8 questions.
Interview questions [1]
Question 1
1. Tell me about a time when you had together information from multiple sources to solve a problem describe the situation the stuff you took together the information and the outcome
2. Misunderstanding between you and a customer, and you were unable to meet your expectations describe the specific situation the actions that you took and the outcome of the situation
3. Tell me about the situation when you had to adapt existential process or encounter while working on an assignment at work or during college please describe the situation how you adapted to the change and the results
4. Think about a time when you need to learn something new in order to accomplish a task at work or during college, please describe the situation your actions and the outcome
I applied online. I interviewed at Progressive Insurance (Colorado Springs, CO)
Interview
Met the minimum requirements, then I got a link to the four part assessment. Once I passed the assessment, almost right away I got an invite to a HireVue interview. Finally, I got to interview with real people.
Interview questions [1]
Question 1
Tell me about a time when you had to deal with a difficult customer.
It was a fairly lengthly process which involved the application, an assessment, pre-recorded one way interview, and a live virtual interview. Asked behavior-based STAR questions. It was extensive with at least 10 questions.